personally i think your eclecticness is you 'thing'
yes choosing a single style has its benefits for SEO - but looking through your store is like going to an antique market, or auction - you never know what you'll uncover - and that imho is a great thing!
I agree. But on the other hand, I would love to have a line that people see a piece from and know "that's a Paisley Lizard" design. But I don't want everything I make to be just variations on theme. Bo-ring. I don't call myself creatively distracted for nuthin'. I have craft ADD.